You know the one. And I’ve been tagged.
1. Professor Bhaer from Little Women – He is kind, good, masculine, and thoroughly resistant to pomposity. My heart was in my throat the first time he knocked on the Marches’ door and thought Jo had married Laurie. He was so vulnerable and strong all at once. Sniff.
When I first fell for Az the Husband, he reminded me of Bhaer (and also the man born blind from John 9). When I saw the movie version I was utterly disgusted that Gabriel Byrne played Bhaer as a beardless man. If he doesn’t have a beard, he IS NOT Mr. Bhaer.
2. Lord Peter Wimsey – He’s clever and classy, deceptively strong and devilishly attractive. All the women swoon for him, and I would be one of them.
3. Mervyn Bunter – I suspect he has a hidden rakish side, and I would like to know more.
Of course, he is Wimsey’s closest friend so maybe I should not snog them both, but they both are firm believers that a gentleman doesn’t kiss and tell, so I think I could pull it off.
4. T.H. White’s Galahad – I admire his good qualities, but he is so serious and boring. If ever a man needed a good snog, it’s this one.
5. Allan Quatermain – He has a certain adventurous manliness I find appealing, combined with a wistful longing for lost love. I suspect, though, that he is strictly a one-woman man, and since the woman he loves usually dies, I hesitate to become one. Maybe instead of snogging we can share lots of lingering glances, filled with a longing for a love that cannot be.
6. Eve and BubandPie mentioned characters from the Lord of the Rings, but none of them appeal to me. Aragorn has that whole eternal love thing going with someone else, and Legolas, well, I think an elf would make me feel like a bearded dwarfwoman. Faramir is a little too perfect. But Beorn from The Hobbit – now there’s a man for me. There is something about the gruff and growly/nurturing and compassionate combo that I find sexy. I’d even become a vegetarian if he asked very, very nicely.
7. Jacob Witting from Sarah, Plain and Tall – He is hard-working and a loving father. His courtship of Sarah is eager but patient, certain he and his family are worth loving, but uncertain whether Sarah will consider them worth the loss of her beloved ocean. The story is tersely told, but I can happily fill in many details, and Jacob is definitely a good kisser.
8. Laurie King’s Sherlock Holmes – Intellect and passion carefully disciplined. He would make a lousy father, but not a bad snog.
9. Remus Lupin – Am I the only one who finds werewolves more than a little intriguing? A werewolf who has managed to control his transformations, who knows his own terrible weaknesses and fights them – that is a man I want to know better.
10. Tennyson’s Arthur – Lancelot was a schmuck. If I had been Guenivere, it would have been Arthur all the way.
I share a similar theme in my choices to BubandPie’s. Strength carefully molded into compassion, passion funneled into faithfulness and patience – it’s like Anne of Green Gables said, “I don’t want someone who is truly wicked, just someone who could be wicked – but won’t.” That’s not an exact quote but you get the idea. Add a few hypermasculine qualities like hairiness and skill at hunting or fighting, and I am hooked.
And if you think that tells you something about Az the Husband, then oh yes it does, sister.

Mm. I was thinking about dear Fritz this morning, I think I’m a John Brooke girl however….
Oh, BUNTER! I nearly put him on my list, couldn’t think of anything quite clever enough to say and so didn’t.
But hands off, sister. Bunter is mine.
I like a certain quiet yearning decency in men, combined with a manly sensitivity. Or for them to be Humphrey Bogart. One or the other.
The most fun part of this is seeing the characters I considered but decided against – and how different people are choosing different characters from the same book. There’s got to be a personality quiz in there somewhere: are you a Sirius/Remus/Severus girl? Are you the kind who goes for Laurie, or Prof. Bhaer, or John Brooke?
I’m glad someone obliged quickly and tagged you.
Some d*mn good lists starting to float around . . . including this one . . . it will be tough not to be influenced should I take this one up!
Remus Lupin. Intriguing. I hadn’t considered him before, but I can see what you mean.
Lord Peter Wimsey all the way. I had such a crush on him that I gobbled up all the books in like, two weeks.
I love your closing paragraph and the comparison to Az. It sounds like you married a good one!
“When I first fell for Az the Husband, he reminded me of Bhaer (and also the man born blind from John 10). ” this sounds worthy of a blog post to me!
Az and Beorn certainly share some characteristics ~a gracious and hospitable contrarian, a good story-teller, loves those entrusted to in his care (family, animals or plants), and can be intimidating if provoked to anger. Did Beorn have a beard? Can Az turn into a bear?
Veronica you continue to crack me up.
brother
brother, Beorn did have a beard (at least I remember it that way). As for Az turning into a bear – only he knows for sure.
Ha ha ha. I have completed my own warped influenced version. It’s kind of literary… just kind of…
Ah, I may well have to steal this one. Great job!
Veronica, what?! Aragorn has another love?!
I thought I was the only one…
P.S. Tennyson’s Arthur and Remus Lupin: thumbs up!
Remus, huh? I see it, but I’m definitely more of the Sirius type. He’s one hot dog! (I know…lame, but I couldn’t resist)
You’re list is so different from mine! There are few on yours that I’m not familiar with (Whimsy and Bunter…haven’t read that particular series) but it appears as if we are polar opposites regarding our taste in men. Still, I can definitely appreciate the appeal of Prof. Bhaer, Lupin, and Arthur.
I only know Allan Quartermain vaguely, but he seems like an apt choice as well. I will always and forever see him as Sean Connery though, which is not necessarily a bad thing. It’s just that I didn’ thave the opportunity to form any kind of mental image of him prior to that so any opinion of him that I would form now, would undoubtedly be tainted by that.
Yes, Lupin is my cup of tea too. I did this over at my place – Beck and B&P’s posts were so much fun I could not resist.
I wish I’d thought of Jacob Witting!
Lord Wimsey be still my heart. I think it is the British accent. It gets me everytime. I agree that I would pick Arthur hand down over Lancelot.
Yet the British accent does get to women all the time. I have learned to laugh about young cashiers’ and waitresses of both sexes falling into a swoon when my husband opens his mouth.
First-time visitor here (via Bub and Pie, to whom I’m also new), and I already know I’ll be back for more.
I love your choices (Arthur over Lancelot seven ways from Sunday – especially the Clive Owen version). The quote from Anne of Green Gables is perfect, and is as good an explanation as any for why I love my husband, too. Great meme!
My answers are finally up. That was WORK. (Okay, not really.)
This is really great! I’ve just done my version and am now looking for other print sex addicts. Giggles about the test of Brooks, Bhaer or Laurie. With you, except for the beards. Love your stuff.
Lupin, eh? Interesting.
And your description of Galahad made me laugh out loud.
[...] let’s call it ‘inspired daydreaming’) that BubandPie has done, which I believe Veronica had the light bulb idea for. I’ve altered my interpretation slightly, because what I’ve [...]
[...] should do this meme: http://toddleddredge.wordpress.com/2007/10/07/that-meme/ I’m tagged for it and won’t get it done right away – so I’m tagging you in [...]